The 1880 season was the first time 11 players made-up a college football team.
FYI: Here's additional seasons when a set number of players were used:
1869--25 player per side
1873--20 players per side
1876--15 players per side
Should you have an interest in learning more about the unique and interesting history of college football, a free subscription to The College Football Historian newsletter is what you are looking for.