Can the Longhorns Live Up to the Hype? A Look at Preseason Expectations

The 2025 college football season approaches with a palpable buzz surrounding the Texas Longhorns. Following three years with Quinn Ewers at quarterback, a new era is dawning in Austin. Arch Manning, a name synonymous with football greatness, is stepping into the starting role.

Manning’s ascendancy brings immense and almost unfathomable expectations from fans and media alike. These expectations reach a critical mass even before his first start as the undisputed No. 1 quarterback. Questions abound whether any athlete could truly meet such a monumental wave of hype.

This article explores the specific expectations placed upon the Longhorns and Manning, examining the realities of their challenging path ahead. The spotlight is intensely bright on Texas and its new quarterback.

The Arch Manning Era Officially Commences

A significant shift is underway for the Texas Longhorns football program. With quarterback Quinn Ewers declaring for the NFL Draft after his three years under center, the highly anticipated Arch Manning era has officially begun.

Manning will make his first start as the team's unquestioned No. 1 quarterback when the Longhorns travel to Columbus for a rematch against the Ohio State Buckeyes. This moment marks a new beginning for Texas football, particularly for its future in the SEC.

It also brings with it significant, almost unfathomable, expectations for the young signal-caller, even before he takes his first snap as QB1. The Longhorns anticipate a strong beginning under his leadership.

Unprecedented Personal Acclaim for Manning

The hype surrounding Arch Manning has reached extraordinary levels, far beyond typical preseason buzz. Even prior to his commitment to Texas, his football heritage and recruiting profile placed him on a unique pedestal.

Now, with only two starts and fewer than 100 career passes, the excitement has intensified dramatically. Manning has already been named a front-runner for the 2025 Heisman Trophy. There are early projections for him to be the No. 1 overall selection in the 2026 NFL Draft.

This remarkable level of pre-season recognition has occurred before his first start as the undisputed starting quarterback. Unsurprisingly, Texas Longhorns odds have shifted dramatically in response, with sportsbooks adjusting lines based on the belief that Manning could deliver an elite-level performance from day one.

Texas Elevated to Preseason National Title Favorite

The Longhorns are also basking in significant team-wide preseason accolades. Many national polls and media outlets have already ranked Texas as the "way-too-early 2025 preseason No. 1 team". This top ranking is largely attributed to Arch Manning's presence and perceived potential.

ESPN's Football Power Index (FPI), a measure designed to reflect a team's strength, notably placed the Longhorns at the top of their rankings by a substantial margin. This strong position highlights the faith placed in the team's potential. Their high ranking sets the stage for a truly high-stakes season.

Questioning the Immense Scale of Expectations

Despite the excitement, questions linger about whether anyone could truly satisfy the current level of hype surrounding Manning and the Longhorns. The expectations from the Texas Longhorns fan base are notably unrealistic.

For example, previous quarterback Quinn Ewers led his team to the College Football Playoff for a second consecutive year in 2024. He reached an SEC title game, and defeated major rivals like Oklahoma and Texas A&M.

Ewers also threw for nearly 3,500 yards and over 30 touchdowns, a statistical season ranking among the best in school history. He finished third all-time at Texas in career passing yards and touchdowns. Yet, many fans erroneously pushed for Manning to replace Ewers. These are the immense and unrelenting expectations Manning will face.

The Challenges of a Significant Roster Overhaul

Beyond the immense expectations, the Longhorns face substantial roster changes that could impact their 2025 season performance:

• The team lost four of its five offensive line starters,
• Their top tight end, the 2 running back, and their top three receivers also departed for the NFL Draft,
• On the defensive side, four top defensive linemen moved on,
• Two key defensive backs, Jahdae Barron and Andrew Mukuba, are gone.

Less than half of their starters from the Cotton Bowl will return for the upcoming season. These significant personnel changes create a formidable rebuilding task. The team will rely heavily on new talent stepping up quickly.

ESPN's Bill Connelly highlighted these departures, suggesting Texas will only be the No. 1 team if Arch Manning performs at an All-American level.

Manning's Innate Resilience and Focus

Fortunately, Arch Manning possesses an inherent ability to handle and disregard such intense scrutiny. While the path ahead will not be easy, he is not expected to be overwhelmed by the pressure.

This spring, Manning is diligently working with his new-look offense and head coach Steve Sarkisian. He will enter the fall season with a clear intention: to lead his team to a national title. His focus remains on the task at hand, aiming to tune out all the external noise.

Whether this effort culminates in a national title and a Heisman Trophy for Manning is yet to be seen. However, he will undoubtedly be at the center of college football's biggest stories from August 31 until January 19.

Defining Success Amidst the Noise

The Texas Longhorns and Arch Manning embark on a season unlike any other, loaded with unprecedented expectations. Success for Manning, as measured by some, would require a national title, a Heisman Trophy, and breaking every single-season school passing record.

The true measure of Texas’s achievement may lie in how effectively they navigate the immense pressure and integrate a talented, albeit unproven, roster. Manning’s individual journey, alongside the team's performance, will undoubtedly capture national attention.

Even if Manning falls short of the extreme benchmarks set for him, his impact will define the narrative for the 2025 college football season.

Can the Longhorns Live Up to the Hype? A Look at Preseason Expectations to SEC Sports Fan Blog

Top of this Page